Sometimes It’s About the Rules You Learned Long Before You Became a Mom
You forgot Spirit Week.
Again.
Not the entire week. Just Pajama Day.
Your child survived. They wore normal clothes. Nobody called CPS. And yet somehow you’ve spent the last three hours mentally reviewing the evidence that you’re failing as a mother.
Maybe you’ve replayed the last twenty parenting podcasts, Instagram posts, therapy blogs, and bestselling parenting books you’ve consumed—gathering fresh evidence that yes, once again, you did it all wrong and your child is now destined to suffer because they showed up in jeans instead of flannel pajamas.
If you’ve ever apologized because dinner came from Costco, felt guilty for enjoying a few hours away from your children, or found yourself lying awake replaying a parenting interaction from six hours ago, you’re not alone.
Many of the women I work with carry a quiet sense of guilt almost everywhere they go.
When they’re working, they wonder if they should be with their children.
When they’re with their children, they wonder if they’re neglecting work.
When they’re taking care of themselves, they worry they’re being selfish.
When they’re taking care of everyone else, they’re exhausted.
No matter what they do, there’s often a lingering feeling that they should be doing more. Doing better. Trying harder.
And despite what that inner critic insists, the problem usually isn’t that you’re not doing enough. The problem may be that you’ve learned to hold yourself responsible for far more than any one human being could possibly carry.
The Real Question Isn’t “Why Do I Feel Guilty?”
The more interesting question is:
Why do I feel responsible for everything?
Many women who struggle with chronic mom guilt didn’t suddenly develop it when they had children. Long before motherhood, they learned strict internal rules like:
Other people’s feelings are your responsibility.
Being a good person means putting yourself last.
If someone is disappointed, you’ve done something wrong.
Needing help is a burden.
Rest has to be earned.
Making mistakes is dangerous.
These lessons often begin with the best intentions. They can come from family messages, cultural expectations, or religious teachings. But often, these rules were actually early survival strategies.
If you grew up as the “responsible one” or had to manage an adult’s unpredictable moods to keep the peace, hyper‑responsibility became your armor.
And it’s also worth remembering that mom guilt doesn’t show up the same way in every culture. Different communities teach different things about responsibility, emotional labor, and what it means to be a “good mother.” In some communities where caregiving is shared more collectively, mothers aren’t expected to carry everything alone — there are more hands, more eyes, more adults in the mix. And in more individualistic cultures, where the unspoken rule is that a “good mother” manages it all herself, guilt can settle in much faster.
None of this is about personal inadequacy. It’s simply the environment you grew up in — the expectations you absorbed long before you ever became a parent.
And when those old rules get activated, the brain can start treating disappointment like danger. That’s why the guilt can feel so immediate, so physical, and so hard to think your way out of.
Your chest tightens, your stomach drops, and your brain starts sprinting—not because you’re failing, but because your nervous system learned long ago that mistakes didn’t feel safe.
It’s like anxiety found the world’s most demanding performance review and decided to conduct it daily. And when that inner critic starts reviewing the evidence at 2:00 AM, your body treats a missed Pajama Day like an actual, high-stakes emergency.
Sometimes Guilt Is Actually Grief
This is the part we don’t talk about enough. And sometimes, what we call mom guilt isn’t guilt at all.
Sometimes it’s grief.
Grief for the version of motherhood you imagined.
Grief for the support you thought you’d have.
Grief for the career opportunities that became harder to pursue.
Grief for uninterrupted sleep.
Let’s be honest—sometimes grief for being able to go to Target alone.
Grief for the parts of yourself that feel harder to find these days.
Many mothers feel ashamed of these losses. They tell themselves they should just feel grateful. As if gratitude is supposed to magically cancel out every other emotion.
Unfortunately, emotions don’t work like a math equation.
Grief and gratitude can exist at the same time.
You can love your children deeply and still miss parts of your old life. You can feel thankful and overwhelmed. You can be a wonderful mother and still struggle.
Those experiences are not mutually exclusive.
They’re just part of being human.
A Tool I Often Share With Clients: The Responsibility Pie
The next time guilt shows up and triggers that old anxiety, try this.
Take out a piece of paper and draw a large circle.
Write down the situation that’s making you feel guilty. Maybe it’s:
“My child had a meltdown at school.”
“My teenager is having a really hard time.”
Then start dividing the pie into every factor that may be contributing.
Include things like:
Your child’s temperament and developmental stage
Friendships and school environment
Sleep, stress, and life transitions
Personality differences
Parenting choices
Many mothers I work with initially give themselves about 95% of the pie. Then they pause and realize they’ve assigned themselves responsibility for things they don’t actually control.
In fact, some women manage to give themselves 110% of the responsibility, which is impressive considering that’s not actually how percentages work.
The goal isn’t to avoid accountability.
It’s to take responsibility only for the part that genuinely belongs to you.
Not 95%.
Just your slice.
What Healthy Motherhood Actually Looks Like
Healthy motherhood isn’t preventing every disappointment; it’s helping children learn they can survive disappointment.
It’s not eliminating every mistake; it’s repairing after mistakes.
It’s not sacrificing yourself until there’s nothing left; it’s showing your children what it looks like to be a whole person.
A person who has limits.
A person who rests.
A person who gets things wrong sometimes.
A person who treats herself with compassion.
The irony is that many mothers extend more kindness to strangers than they do to themselves.
If that’s you, consider this your reminder:
The fact that you worry about being a good mother is usually evidence that you’re trying very hard to be one.
In all my years as a therapist, I’ve yet to meet the truly indifferent parent who lies awake wondering if they’re doing enough.
And sometimes, the most loving thing you can do isn’t trying harder.
It’s putting down responsibility that was never yours to carry in the first place.
A Note for the Weary Mother
If you try the Responsibility Pie and find that your brain agrees you only own 5% of the pie, but your gut still feels 100% guilty, you aren’t doing it wrong.
Those old rules are deeply wired into your nervous system.
Knowing something isn’t your fault and feeling like it’s your fault are often two very different experiences.
That’s why self-compassion can feel so difficult. It’s why reassurance doesn’t always stick. And it’s why many women find themselves carrying responsibility long after they’ve realized it was never theirs to begin with.
Change is possible. Those old patterns aren’t permanent.
With support, practice, and sometimes therapy, many women find they can respond to guilt differently—not because they’ve become perfect mothers, but because they no longer feel responsible for everything.
You are safe.
You are human.
And you can let the rest of the pie go.
Until We Meet Again
Until we meet again — breathe gently, walk slowly, and treat yourself with kindness.
— Iris
If you’re considering therapy and would like to learn more about working together, you’re welcome to reach out.
Get in Touch
About the Author
I’m Iris Hogan-Schmidt, LICSW, a Seattle-based therapist. I support women navigating anxiety, trauma, maternal mental health challenges, and life transitions through a trauma-informed, collaborative approach. My work draws on EMDR, mindfulness, self-compassion, and values-based therapies, tailored to each client’s needs.
A Note About the Examples in This Article
To protect confidentiality, any client stories or examples shared here are composites inspired by common experiences rather than descriptions of any specific individual. Details have been changed to preserve privacy while illustrating themes that may resonate with readers.
Therapy for Women Across Washington: EMDR, Anxiety & Maternal Health
Evidence-based treatments for anxiety, stress, trauma, and maternal health.
If you would like to connect for support, you can schedule a time to meet here.